Trying to think of better excuses since 1995

Halfass header image 2

Justice in Music

May 31st, 2004 · 5 Comments

Metafilter” just sent me to this great Frontline interview with David Crosby during which he touches on the future of the record companies:

Now they’re going in the tank, because the world has changed, and they did not change with it. They bit the poison pill, without realizing it, when they went digital. Once a thing is in digital domain, it can be copied as many times as you want. And there is no system that can keep it from being copied. You can devise the most clever one you want, and I will bring some little geek with a pen protector in his pocket into the room and he will fix it in a minute. …

Yes! Justice is ours!

I remember when CDs occupied a tiny corner of my local record store. The technology aspect of them was seductive—high tech labeling ( remember DDD?), lasers, cardboard longboxes - but the price was prohibitive (something over $20.00 in the eighties when a record was $6.98$8.99). I stuck with records for two reasons: the price and the artwork, despite being prodded by every marketing effort that CDs were the future. I remember Martha Quinn, the original MTV VJ, talking about how great they were and throwing one around like a frisbee to demonstrate its permanence. The lies were endless. We were told the CD would last forever, was indestructible, was a perfect digital copy of the original recording.

Of all the promises, only one was true: a digital copy would last forever. What the record companies didn’t tell us was that the disks themselves wouldn’t last and it would be up to “the network” to preserve them.

Eventually, the companies pushed vinyl out, and began selling “albums” at nearly twice the price. Record companies reported record profits, and thing were gangbusters.

Now, they’re on the verge of the the end. And I’m glad for it. Because I know that music will continue.

I’m not saying that music will be free, nor advocating piracy or copyright violation. I’m just illustrating that record companies thought (and still think) that they are the only game in town and the only way for the people to hear new artists and tunes, but they are so wrong. Here’s why: the business has changed.

When asked if the “new model” works out, David enthusiastically responds:

You bet. And I’m going to get a lot more. No packaging cost, no promotion, no lairs of distributors, each taking 20 percent off as it goes by. No returns, no free goods, nada! [laughter] No costs! That’s a good business model that works…

Smart companies (like, hopefully, Apple) will open their distribution networks, and the Internet world will take care of the marketing. P2P, Bittorrent, DRM—it’s all going to come together and bring the music to us the way we want it. Guaranteed.

Tags: MP3 and Digital Music · Music

5 responses so far ↓

  • 1 Elliott // Jun 1, 2004 at 4:20 pm

    Justice perhaps, but the sound, the sound is gone.

    Not only do records sound better than CD’s, but records from analog tapes sound better than records from digitally remastered tapes. My wife and I merged our record collections. She had an old copy of “Let it Bleed” and I had the digtally remastered version. We played them both, and, scratches and all, her copy was just slamming by comparison.

  • 2 Scott Partee // Jun 2, 2004 at 12:03 am

    Yes, but this has been true since CDs were forced upon us.

    I predict CDs will vanish, vinyl will not.

  • 3 Wisdom // Jun 3, 2004 at 11:45 am

    Agree regarding LP vs. CD sound – recently upgraded my Phono and dragged out all of my LP’s and have taken great joy in listening to them again. I think one of my biggest thrills this year was when I found a guy with 8 boxes of LP’s at a garage sale for $.50 apiece. I walked out with about 40 of them – original Apple pressings, 80’s stuff and jazz. Wonderful!

    Regarding digital music distribution, I wholeheartedly agree with David’s assessment. The RIAA and Labels have had 5 years to come to an agreement with one another and figure out a digital distribution scheme that will work and that customers will actually pay for, yet they fritter their time and money chasing after file swappers and infuriating their customer base. Fools! I’ve been boycotting all RIAA music (through pay channels) for over a year now, directing my dollars toward non-RIAA labels & artists.

    Check this out: http://www.magnetbox.com/riaa/

  • 4 Sean MaGee // Jul 19, 2004 at 3:18 am

    digital is good if you are a robot!!!!you want to lessen internet/music piracy, stick to analog! F@#K DIGITAL

  • 5 Sean MaGee // Jul 19, 2004 at 3:19 am

    digital is good if you are a robot!!!!you want to lessen internet/music piracy, stick to analog! F!!! DIGITAL

Leave a Comment